Firehouse Pizza Wood-Fired in Casper, WY

Basic Information:

Pizza: Firehouse Pizza Wood-Fired

Number of Locations: 1
Location Reviewed: 395 Newport Road in Casper, WY (across the parking lot from Kohl's)
Website: https://firehousepizzawoodfired.com/
Date of Review Visit: September 2026
What I Ordered: 12" pizza with pepperoni and sausage
Price: $13.65 (pizza only; includes tax but not drink or tip)
Photo:

Summary Review: 3 stars (out of 5)

 

Detailed Review:

Crust: Firehouse Pizza Wood-Fired has a crust that is thicker than you would expect for wood-fired pizza.  The crust has the usual blackened spots.  It doesn't have much taste, and the texture is a little on the hard side, but only a little.  I've had better crusts, but this crust isn't terrible.  Score: 6/10

Sauce: This pizza does not have much sauce, and what sauce does appear tastes on the spicy side.  I guess this sauce is the reason they call this pizza Firehouse.  This is not my favorite sauce.  Score: 3/10

Cheese: The cheese appears in adequate quantity, and it does not produce too much grease.  Score: 8/10

Toppings: The pepperoni comes in big but thin slices that have a nice spiced pork flavor.  The sausage comes in tiny ground-up pieces that have no discernable flavor.  This pizza needs better sausage.  Both toppings appear in adequate quantity.  Score: 7/10

Overall Taste: The sauce is too spicy for my taste palette, and otherwise the taste is quite bland.  The pepperoni saves a real disaster.  Score: 6/10

Pizza Appearance: The large slices of pepperoni catch the eye.  Otherwise, the appearance is very average.

Dining Atmosphere: I ordered take-out, but Firehouse Pizza Wood-Fired has a modern and functional dining room.

Customer Service: The service was fast and friendly on my visit.

Monetary Value: The quality is not great, but also this pizza is not very expensive.  Therefore, the value is about average.

The Final Judgment:

In a region with few restaurants that fire up pizza ovens, Firehouse Pizza Wood-Fired gets the job done, but that's about it.  My heart isn't on fire for this pizza, but I'm not ready to fire it from my pizza rotation either.  Score: 70/100